KNOL – Uh… Is that how bongs pronounce Null?
Knol is this ‘hot’ new venture from Google.com. The same guys who also brought us that incredible search engine that we all so love and use. Knol’s supposed to be a take on Knowledge, a unit of knowledge if you please. At least that’s what the guys at Google think it is. It’s supposed to be the wikipedia "killer". The secret weapon that will take eyeballs away from wikipedia and stick ‘em right where Google wants ‘em.
No matter what Google calls Knoll, and no matter what Google wants it to be, right now the only thing that Knol stands for, is NULL. In CAPITAL letters.
I heard about Knol a few months ago, and when the public beta was launched I expected it to be simple, responsive, effective, and useful, like most products from Google. But this website seems like it was made by Microsoft! It sticks, doesn’t and for most parts is TOTALLY useless.
Knull content
If you go to the Knol frontpage, you will find a lot of articles on medicine. It seems Google’s out to cure a sick world, but that’s not what I was looking for. I found no catigorisation, and no way to reach the freshly submitted articles. Don’t even ask me about the search, almost everything I fed in was MISSING from Knol. In fact I looked for terms from the article I had submitted in the morning, and found nothing. Is this the famous Google search technology, or have they really started recruiting monkeys to filter search results?
Knull policy
Reports on Knol suggest that Google doesn’t plan to edit, or whet the articles submitted to Knol, but judging from the reports that I got from other submitters, the article don’t show up on Knol immediately. Is there some kind of sand-box, or verification going on? If yes then why isn’t the user informed?
The world is U-S-A (Knull Globe)
Google’s got pretty big, and one would like to think that they’re finally ready to go global. You know like Pepsi, Coke and Heinz, but not the folks at Google.com. The world for them is the USA, and nobody else is supposed to submit an article to Knol. When you try to do a name verification, you will be taken to a page which lists only one country: USA. The others simply don’t exist! What the!? Am I in some sort of virtual reality place called India that Google isn’t aware of? Or, how hard is it to put a note that says, "Name verification is only available for USA at the moment."
Knull Future!
That’s what Knol has plenty of. A great big amount of NO future. Not if there are some changes fast. Why did the header keep saying Sign in when I was already signed in? Why isn’t there any kind of organized directory or reference? Why aren’t there tags? Why isn’t there a way to show article popularity (Since Knol will have multiple articles on the same topic). Why isn’t there a way to see other articles on the same topic? Why hasn’t Google fired the guy who took Knol live so prematurely, and so crappily?
